Global warming

Robert M. Neil uarn at MCK-UAII.MCK.NCSU.EDU
Thu Oct 23 11:48:53 MDT 1997

I agree with Gary. While theories of global warming ought NOT to be
dismissed simply as "junk science", neither is there sufficient
evidence that extreme measures need be taken. And I consider a treaty
costing our economy hundreds of billions of dollars to be extreme.

The fact that 80% of the economies of the world are exempt means that
it is also unfair.

On 23 Oct 97 at 12:34, Gary Freitag wrote:

> >I am surprised that a physicist would make such a remark.  I agree, if
> >it
> >exists, its dimensions are unknown.  The question I ask - does that mean
> >the best choice is to just ignore it?  Talk about burying one's head in
> >the
> >sand.
> >Stephen Frye
> Whats needs to be considered is the opportunity cost of spending 100
> billion dollars a year on this issue.  Perhaps the benefits of using
> those resources somewhere else would produce greater benefits.  Add
> to that the great uncertainty as to the effectiveness of taking such
> actions in addressing the problem, or even if the problem exists or
> has anything to do with mankind.
> I am reminded of the acid rain debate in the early 80's and the
> drive to spend billions to clean up smoke stack emmisions on power
> plants. Reagan fought it (by wisdom or luck) on the grounds that not
> enough information was available.  It became clear in the late 80's
> that power plant's contribution was a drop in the bucket compared to
> the automobile.  Had action been taking, it would have been money
> ill spent.
> Anyway, not taking action does not necessarily equate to putting
> your head in the head, its about weighing the alpha risk with the
> beta risk.
> gary
> gfreitag at

Robert Neil
Computing Consultant II
Urban Affairs - NC State University, Box 7401
Raleigh NC 27695   tel: (919) 515-6046  fax: (919) 515-3642
"A candle may light the way in the darkness, but NUCLEAR POWER
 means we can have cold beer while we watch the Superbowl." CS

More information about the Rushtalk mailing list