[Rushtalk] Inside the Painstaking Recovery Process of a Medal of Honor Marine
cwsiv at juno.com
Wed Nov 16 09:47:24 MST 2016
Inside the Painstaking Recovery Process of a Medal of Honor Marine
Six years ago this month Lance Corporal Kyle Carpenter suffered grievous
wounds after shielding another Marine from a grenade blast in
Afghanistan. Somehow, he survived. This is the story of his remarkable
* Thomas James Brennan
November 11, 2016 10:48 am
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
I. The Damage
The thick steel body of the grenade flexed and swelled before exploding
and tearing flesh and bone from Lance Corporal Kyle Carpenter’s face.
The date was November 21, 2010. The place was Marjah, Afghanistan. For
seven days, the extent of Carpenter’s wounds remained a mystery to his
family. Despite e-mails, voicemails, and calls with Marine Corps
representatives, his mother and father knew only that their son was
being evacuated from Afghanistan in critical condition. The military
told them that Kyle had been badly wounded and that his chances of
survival were unknown. On November 25, Thanksgiving Day, Robin and Jim
Carpenter drove 12 hours, slowed by the holiday traffic, from Gilbert,
South Carolina, to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, in
Bethesda, Maryland, to await their son’s arrival. His flight was delayed
because of blood clots in his legs. A flight at high altitude could have
Carpenter arrived at Walter Reed on Sunday, November 28. Robin held his
hand all the way from the ambulance to the elevator taking him to the
intensive-care unit. Carpenter’s head appeared roughly double its normal
size—it was wrapped in gauze and pressure dressings to deal with the
effects of the explosion and the aftermath of emergency brain surgery.
The doctors in Afghanistan had to remove shrapnel before Carpenter could
be flown to Landstuhl, in Germany, and then to Walter Reed. Tubes
protruded from his neck, head, chest, abdomen, and each of his limbs.
The Carpenters had not seen their son in four months. His mother
remembers thinking that Kyle looked worse than anything she had seen
while working as a radiology technician in a trauma hospital. She knew
it was Kyle only because the hospital staff told her it was.
Throughout Kyle’s deployment, Robin had worried that harm would come to
her son. “For the four months Kyle was in Afghanistan, I felt like every
time I came home a car would be sitting in my driveway. I did what I was
supposed to do—the care packages, the letters—but I still feel like I
didn’t have enough faith. My gut told me that he would come home
wounded, or worse.”
VIDEO: Kyle Carpenter’s Recovery
Kyle Carpenter had been wounded when a hand grenade landed beside him
and a fellow Marine in their lookout post. Without hesitation, Kyle
lunged toward the explosive to shield his friend from the blast. He was
wearing body armor, which offered some protection for his torso, but the
exploding grenade left entry and exit wounds in his skull, shredded his
face, severed major arteries, splintered his right arm, collapsed a
lung, and left him hemorrhaging beneath a plume of grey smoke. For his
action in Marjah, Carpenter would be awarded the Medal of Honor.
Repairing the damage to his body would take years, and in some ways it
is not over. This is the story of Carpenter’s recovery.
II. Patrol Base Dakota
The squad of Marines had spent the night of November 20 patrolling open
fields and deep canals. Doing so was safer than using the roads. The men
were four months into a seven-month deployment, and Private First Class
Jared Lilly had already seen two of his friends killed by explosives.
Others had been wounded by gunfire. Lilly and his 1,000-man unit were
spread across fortified bases inside Taliban territory. That relative
comfort and safety was now at an end. Lilly and the rest of his 14-man
squad had just moved to an even more remote and dangerous location.
In a village, the Marines took over a compound—a collection of buildings
behind 10-foot-high mud walls—to use as its patrol base, which they
called Dakota. The compound had been commandeered from a local family,
which was evicted. Before sunrise, more than 250 sandbags had been
hand-filled and stacked into makeshift guard posts. A request for heavy
equipment to fortify the new patrol base had been denied hours before
the mission began. Instead, the Marines chiseled at the ground with
There were walls at Patrol Base Dakota, but the enemy could maneuver
within 30 yards of the Marines unseen. A canal ran alongside the
compound, lined thickly with tall reeds. On the first day the Marines
spent at Dakota, Taliban fighters heaved grenades over the walls. One
Marine took shrapnel to his abdomen. Another had his scrotum peppered
with shards of metal. Later that night, the owner of the compound came
for some of his belongings. He brought a message from the Taliban:
Tomorrow the Marines would be attacked worse than they just had been.
Kyle Carpenter compares his scars in photographs taken shortly after the
injury occurred to the way they exist now at his parent’s house in
Gilbert, South Carolina on May 14, 2016.
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
Sunrise brought machine-gun and sniper fire. A barrage of grenades began
exploding throughout the courtyard. Marines who were sleeping scrambled
to put on their gear. There was a second barrage of grenades, then
screaming in Pashtu: an Afghan soldier had been wounded. Two more
grenades exploded in the courtyard. Then another grenade. Then another.
The last of the explosions came from the rooftop of one of the
buildings. Two Marines were known to be there.
Lilly sprinted to the building and up the rungs of a wooden ladder,
charging into the dust and smoke. Lance Corporal Nick Eufrazio was lying
on his back. He had been hit by shrapnel and appeared to be unconscious.
In a corner, Kyle Carpenter lay face down in a widening pool of blood.
Lilly reached for his arm. It squished limply in his hand. Carpenter’s
face was torn into four separate flaps of flesh. Lilly placed
tourniquets on each of Kyle’s arms. One of them was so badly mangled
that Lilly worried he would cinch down too tight and “pop his arm right
off.” Carpenter gasped for breath, his chest heaving.
The squad’s Navy medical corpsman, Christopher Frend, had treated many
casualties before, but had never seen anything like Carpenter. His arm
was so shattered that Frend felt as though he was splinting a wet rag.
Carpenter’s right eye had nearly fallen from its socket. The corpsman
inserted a tube through a nostril hoping it would help Carpenter breath.
It didn’t. When Frend removed the tubing, Carpenter sprayed teeth,
flesh, blood, and mucus from his nose. He was trying to speak. His
tongue seemed to be searching for the rest of his jaw. He was asking,
“Am I going to die?” The Marines on the triage team began reminding Kyle
of stories he had told them about life at home. The more they talked
about his family, the more stable he became.
Kyle’s mother, Robin Carpenter, remembers the days after she found out
her son was injured at her home in Gilbert, South Carolina on May 14,
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
III. Aboard the C-17
The rotors of the medical evacuation helicopter thumped in the distance
as it flew toward Patrol Base Dakota. Lilly and four others carried the
wounded to the landing zone on nylon sheets. Lilly thought he’d never
see Carpenter alive again. He heaved his helmet across the patrol base
and sat with his back against the wall. Tears dripped onto his
cigarette. Other Marines began cleaning off the blood on his skin and
uniform with baby wipes.
Aboard the helicopter, the medics triaged Carpenter’s wounds. When his
heart stopped, the team worked to revive him: chest compression, fluids,
drugs. There was a heartbeat—and then it was gone. Once more he was
revived, and for the moment stabilized. Upon arrival at Camp Bastion,
Carpenter’s admission code was given as “P.E.A.,” the military acronym
for Patient Expired Upon Arrival. But he wasn’t P.E.A. at all.
Neurosurgeons removed shrapnel from his brain. Vascular surgeons
repaired his veins and arteries. Torn flesh was stretched and sutured;
nothing cosmetic—that could wait. Stopping blood loss and preserving
tissue was more important. Carpenter was wrapped in pressure dressings
and stiffened with splints. The medical team’s goal was to get him
stable enough to fly to Germany and then to the United States. The
medical staff at Walter Reed could rebuild him. He just needed to stay
alive until he got there.
On Thanksgiving, Carpenter was cleared to fly to Germany. Only after he
arrived at Landstuhl was his mother able to speak to her son. Carpenter
was in a medically induced coma, and his state of awareness is unknown.
But a nurse held a phone to his ear when Robin and her family called.
They remember the nurse telling her that Kyle’s heart raced on the
monitor every time she spoke.
After two days in Germany, allowing blood clots to dissolve, Carpenter
was wheeled aboard a U.S. Air Force C-17 transport airplane. The
airplane was fitted with two intensive-care bays: the second one was for
an Army sergeant named Ryan Craig. More than 150 other service members
were on the plane, the majority of them ambulatory patients—“walking
For nearly a week, Ryan Craig’s mother, Jennifer Miller, had been in
Germany with her son. Next of kin are normally flown to Landstuhl only
if a patient is terminal. “I got a call at 5:22 a.m. from somebody in
Afghanistan who said Ryan was hurt,” Miller recalled. “They didn’t give
me many details . . . . that my son’s injuries were not
life-threatening. At 8 a.m. they told us about a gunshot to the helmet.
By 11:30 a.m., . . . they told us the bullet hit his head, but didn’t
penetrate. . . . . At 2:30 p.m., they told me they’d removed part of his
skull. By 5 p.m., I was going to Germany.”
Like Carpenter’s mother, Miller had decades of experience working in a
trauma hospital. She assumed her trip was to give approval for doctors
to remove her son from life support. But no: he was still hanging on,
and stable enough to be transported. Jennifer was harnessed into a seat
among the doctors and nurses. Once the plane reached cruising altitude,
Jennifer alternated between talking to her own son and to Robin’s. She
said to Carpenter, though he remained unconscious: “I’m not your mom,
but I am a mom. We’re going back to the United States. You’re going
The flight from Germany took more than 12 hours. At one point Craig went
into cardiac arrest. Doctors re-started his heart as the aircraft
descended by 10,000 feet to help increase cabin pressure. Craig and
Carpenter survived the flight, and after landing at Dover Air Force
Base, in Delaware, they were loaded into ambulances. Miller stared out
the back window of the one carrying Ryan, blue and red lights flashing
in the darkness—mother and son speeding toward a recovery that is still
ongoing today. She could see Carpenter’s ambulance behind theirs, the
white and yellow lines of the highway trailing behind. Police blockades
closed off intersections as the ambulances sped toward Walter Reed.
Sergeant Jared Lilly at Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune, North Carolina
on May 16, 2016.
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
IV. “We’re Going to Save It”
Carpenter’s parents were inside the main lobby. So was Tiffany Aguiar, a
friend of Nick Eufrazio’s, the man Carpenter had tried to shield.
Eufrazio had suffered severe head injuries and was already at Walter
Reed. As the ambulance pulled up, Robin and Jim rushed outside. Aguiar
stood motion-less when she saw Carpenter. Very little of his face was
visible, but the parts that were exposed were “scarred and
indistinguishable,” she recalled. Robin’s face left an impression just
as deep. “I could never, ever imagine my parents being in that
situation,” Aguiar said. “The image of a mother seeing her son come back
from war like that is something that doesn’t leave you.”
Walter Reed’s chief of trauma surgery is Dr. Debra Malone. She prepared
to evaluate Kyle. When a patient arrives, Malone explained, treatment
starts over. The medical team ordered a full body CAT scan. An angiogram
was administered to gauge whether the blood flow to the injured parts of
his body was sufficient. Because Kyle had been revived twice during his
medical evacuation, and because he had been given 12 pints of blood, the
team wondered how much more his immune system could withstand. Dozens of
x-rays were taken before his treatment strategy was presented to
orthopedic, vascular, reconstructive, and trauma surgeons.
“There’s no recipe book for combat trauma or medicine,” Malone said.
“Someone can be stable and their wounds can look clean, and a few
seconds, minutes, hours, or days later, things can look very different.
It’s a difficult thing to explain to patients and their families. It’s
not a journey on a flat paved asphalt road; it’s a journey through a
treacherous mountainous path.” And then? And then, she said, if
everything goes well, “eventually you make it to a beautiful meadow.
That’s the rest of your life.”
Carpenter had a long way to go. Because his right arm was shattered—a
total of 34 fractures, the bones broken into shards—his mother was
worried that the doctors would need to amputate. “We’re not taking his
arm,” Malone’s team told her. “We’re going to save it.”
During the weeks and months ahead, Robin made her home in the waiting
room. Jim had gone back to South Carolina—to his job as a poultry
salesman and to the couple’s two other sons, Price and Peyton, both
teenagers. A woman named Janine Canty introduced herself to Robin upon
Kyle’s arrival and grew close to Kyle and his family. She wasn’t a
doctor, nor was she part of the staff at Walter Reed. She was a case
manager with the Semper Fi Fund, a nonprofit assistance organization
that helps wounded, ill, and injured Marines and sailors. Her husband
was a Marine with 27 years of service.
By the time she met Robin, Canty had been with the Semper Fi Fund for
just over four years. In the beginning, Janine didn’t know where to look
or what to say when she walked into a patient’s room. With time, she
became more comfortable asking patients about their injuries—above or
below the knee or elbow, closed or penetrating brain injury. She also
became more comfortable asking families if they needed financial help.
Being around pain, injury, and suffering had somehow become normal for
her, Canty said, but the moments of success and hope made all of it
worthwhile. Families worry about finances when a service member is
wounded. Support allows a family to focus on recovery.
For Robin and Jim, the assistance helped them to travel back and forth
between home and Washington—one of them always with Kyle, the other with
the rest of the family. “I can’t imagine there being another choice—to
be apart—because there were two boys at home and somebody had to raise
them,” Canty said.
Kyle Carpenter flips through one of several photo albums filled with
images relating to his deployment and after at his parent’s house in
Gilbert, South Carolina on May 14, 2016.
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
V: One Step at a Time
Carpenter was in surgery almost weekly. Orthopedic surgeons repaired his
bones. Malone repaired his soft tissue. Other surgeons applied and
repaired skin grafts. Carpenter was treated with leeches to control
blood pooling under the skin. Because his head had borne the brunt of
the blast, dirt and debris were embedded in Carpenter’s face. Malone
referred to the damage as “mud tattoos.” It would take months of
reconstructive surgery and laser treatment to remove it all. The medical
team focused on small successes as a way of boosting morale. Carpenter
himself lived in “a haze of drugs,” as Malone described it.
When he was finally allowed out of that haze, in the spring of 2011,
there were psychological issues to contend with. Malone remembered
visiting with him. “I think it was the first time since his injury that
he was talking to me with a clear mind,” she said. “Other Marines would
always come in to visit him and he didn’t like them seeing him how he
looked. It wasn’t that Kyle seemed self-conscious. He knew they were
deploying to Afghanistan soon, and he didn’t want them to worry more
about being injured like he had been.” Carpenter needed to be medicated
simply in order for the staff to change his bandages. Malone’s medical
notes quote Kyle talking about these procedures: “It is the worst pain I
have ever felt.”
Malone stood by Carpenter when he took his first steps in the hospital.
“When a wounded warrior is about to get out of bed for the first time,”
she said, “everybody knows it is going to happen. We line the hallway
and when they step out of their room we ring a bell and cheer.”
Carpenter was in pain, but he kept walking. Yellow foam cubes encased
his right arm, which itself was held together with hundreds of screws
and dozens of plates. Carpenter circled the nurse’s station with nearly
the entire wing in tow. Chimes echoed throughout the hall.
Carpenter would remain at Walter Reed for another year. Robin rarely
left. She missed the birthdays of her husband and of her other two boys.
She missed sports championships, first dates, family dinners. Throughout
Carpenter’s recovery, Robin and Jim would on occasion meet in Dunn,
North Carolina, roughly halfway between their home and Walter Reed.
Dinner, a kiss, and then off on their separate ways. Sometimes it was
Jim who went north to be with Kyle, Robin heading south for a spell at
What Jim Carpenter cannot forget is the staff at Walter Reed. “When I
first saw Kyle, I didn’t think he would have any quality of life—living
bound to a bed or a wheelchair,” he said. “He kept progressing and I
kept getting my son back. There’s so much weight put on the hospital
staff to repair wounded people—people just torn apart—and they do it day
in and day out. It seems impossible and thankless. It’s Groundhog Day
The drive from Camp Lejeune, North Carolina, to Walter Reed, in
Maryland, takes around six hours. Jared Lilly, the Marine who triaged
Kyle on the rooftop in Afghanistan, made the trip in February 2011. He
was excited but nervous about seeing Kyle for the first time since the
explosion. “Kyle was like the lovable little brother,” Lilly said. “He
was the guy that everybody wanted to be friends with and he was really
nice to everyone, but he was also someone who really enjoyed being by
himself. Most of our platoon ran 20-minute three-mile runs. He could do
it in 15 to 16. He was a serious athlete. But I had no idea what to
expect. The last thing I had in my head was him with his jaw blown off.
I expected him to still be a mess.”
When Lilly parked his car, Kyle and Robin were walking together out of
the entrance to the hospital. “I ran over to him. There was no walking,”
Lilly recalled. “I did not expect him to be walking and when you see
that, wow. . . . . But as you got closer, all the real stuff hit you.
His arm was still in a sling. He was tiny and skinny at this point. You
could see where he had been sewn up—they hadn’t done any plastic surgery
to make him pretty. It was just to save the tissue.” Lilly remembered
looking him over, in awe that the medical team had “put him back
together.” Carpenter’s mind seemed sharp. Lilly wanted to hug and
squeeze his friend, but “didn’t want to break him.”
Kyle and his father, Jim Carpenter, kid around in their back yard in
Gilbert, South Carolina on May 15, 2016.
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
VI. The First Salute
Many years before Carpenter was wounded, Erik Johnson had himself been a
patient one infection away from death. It was 1997 and he was about to
deploy to Bosnia as an Army private. He had been driving a military
vehicle with other soldiers when one of the tires ruptured and sent the
truck flipping end over end. The truck came to a stop when it struck a
street sign and burst into flames. Johnson and another soldier were
trapped inside. His arms and half of his face suffered third-degree
burns. The other soldier died. Johnson endured months of recovery that
included debridement of his burns, a sterile process that involves
scrubbing his flesh with a sponge resembling a Brillo Pad.
Fifteen years later, his own hospitalization was part of what helped him
form a friendship with Carpenter. Kyle had been at Walter Reed for more
than a year when he first met Johnson, who would work with him as his
occupational therapist. Before meeting Carpenter, knowing only what he
could guess from the chart, Johnson anticipated someone frail and with
poor mobility, and perhaps lacking in motivation. To his surprise,
Carpenter walked into his clinic wearing gym shorts, ready to get to
“I asked to look at his grafts and understand his injuries,” Johnson
recalled. “And he wanted to see mine. He was really interested in how
things would look when things matured. We talked about follow-up
procedures and how I had an upcoming surgery with his same surgeon. He
reminded me a lot of myself.”
Carpenter and Johnson were both from South Carolina. Both were Gamecocks
fans. There was plenty to talk about. One of the subjects was pain.
Johnson explained to Carpenter that a position of comfort is a position
of contracture, and that it prevents functional independence. He needed
Carpenter to know that pain is a necessary part of recovery. The two
spoke a lot about Carpenter’s prosthetic eye. For his first one,
Carpenter asked if an image of a Purple Heart could be placed where the
pupil would ordinarily be. The prosthesis team initially told him that
this was impossible—and then found a way to do it, giving him the eye as
Dr. Richard Auth was in charge of Kyle’s facial reconstruction. Because
of the array of injuries to Kyle’s face, the team relied on a variety of
imaging technologies, including magnetic resonance and 3D spiral
multi-slice. The scarring and missing tissue and bone meant that the
skin on Kyle’s face had to be stretched before acrylic teeth could be
implanted into his mouth. Each time Auth met with Carpenter’s mother,
she expressed the hope that she hadn’t lost her son’s smile forever.
Mold after mold was made and refined. In the operating room, Auth kept a
picture of Carpenter before his injuries. He and his team were
determined to give him back his smile.
During years two and three of his recovery, Carpenter was able to spend
some time at home. He undertook occupational therapy with Julie
Durnford, a therapist in Lexington, South Carolina. Carpenter was the
first combat-wounded service member she had ever treated. “His injuries
were challenging and I had been a therapist for 20 years,” Durnford
said. “He couldn’t function normally by any means. He always told me he
wanted his arms to get better so he could stay in the military. He
always looked exhausted by how hard he worked to recover. When he took
any breaks during therapy he would try to motivate the old ladies with
broken wrists or hips. And he always, always made time to speak with any
World War II, Korea, or Vietnam veterans who came into the clinic.
Carpenter began calling her Dr. Julie. She helped him regain some use of
his right hand. It was all about the small successes for Carpenter, she
said. Her favorite moment was when he scratched his own nose for the
first time. His smile was beautiful, she remembered, even with missing
As Carpenter dedicated himself to his recovery, Nick Eufrazio’s friend
Tiffany Aguiar finished college and earned a commission in the Marine
Corps. In August 2012, she graduated from officer candidate school as a
second lieutenant. The first salute is a tradition among Marine
officers: they render the honors to a service member or veteran whom
they respect and admire. Tiffany had hoped Eufrazio would be her first
salute, but owing to his injuries and ongoing therapy he remained
incapacitated. So Carpenter stepped in. He had by now regained much of
the use of his right arm. Standing in front of the Iwo Jima Memorial,
just beyond Arlington National Cemetery, Carpenter and Aguiar faced one
another. Both were wearing their dress blues. Carpenter’s Purple Heart
was pinned to his breast. In his left arm he held a photograph of Nick
Eufrazio. He raised his right hand to the brim.
Kyle Carpenter lies under the oaks of the University of South Carolina’s
Horseshoe on May 13, 2016 where he is currently enrolled as a student
studying International Relations.
Photographs by Eliot Dudik.
VII. A Fresh Eye
Robin Carpenter circled the granite island at the center of her kitchen.
Then she looked out a window, stared at her phone, and wondered where
Kyle was. She had been told that the President of the United States was
about to call. Kyle wasn’t answering. At last he walked in. “Does anyone
have an iPhone charger?” his mother remembered him saying.
On June 19, 2014, William “Kyle” Carpenter was awarded the Medal of
Honor. During the ceremony, Carpenter’s occupational therapist at Walter
Reed, Erik Johnson, noticed something different about his appearance. He
was wearing an ordinary prosthetic eye, not the one with the Purple
Heart pupil. To Johnson, the switch seemed symbolic: Carpenter was no
longer defining himself in terms of his wounds. At the White House,
Carpenter stood among those he had fought alongside—both in the hospital
and on the battlefield. When the Medal of Honor was clasped around his
neck by President Obama, Carpenter was with his family, his friends, his
squad, and nearly all of his medical team.
Since being injured, Kyle has skydived and run marathons. He is a
full-time student at the University of South Carolina. He is a
sought-after public speaker on the issues veterans face as they
reintegrate into the civilian world. “The Marine Corps wasn’t part of my
plan for Kyle,” Robin Carpenter said, looking back. “I still remember
what he said to me when I tried to talk him out of it. ‘If I don’t do
this, it will be someone else’s son.’”
Thomas J. Brennan is the founder of The War Horse, which is a nonprofit
newsroom dedicated to investigating the Departments of Defense and
Veterans Affairs, and which collaborated with Vanity Fair on this
,= ,-_-. =.
America works when American citizens work.
Freedom and open source the GNU paradigm.
Warning: Don't Use Probiotics Before You See This
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Rushtalk